The Amazing $5 Lip Gloss by NYX May 14, 2013 Melissa Meyers I recently tried a new lip gloss that I love from NYX Cosmetics Spring Collection called Butter Gloss. The creamy gloss has sheer to medium coverage without any sticky residue. I love the way it looks and feels on my lips...and, the price is right! NYX Butter Gloss in Merengue. Available at Ulta, $5 Natural light pink lips by NYX Butter Gloss in Merengue, $5. Available in 12 colors.